Warren Oates's Collection
Garcia 01/18/1974
Keystone, Berkeley, CA
| Source | MAC > D > CD > EAC > SHN |
| Media | cdr 4 discs |
| Notes | Garcia & Saunders Recorded by Bob Menke, unknown setup. PATCHED VERSION (discs one and two different from previously circulating version) Finders Keepers, Think, Lala, I Second That Emotion, and My Funny Valentine also circulate as part of the "Dick's Gift" compilation, which is actually 1/17/74 NOT 1/18. jjoops says: "Turns out this is indeed a composite of 1/17/74 and 1/18/74, as follows: Keystone Berkeley 1/17/74: I: Someday Baby, La-la, I Second That Emotion, My Funny Valentine, Who's Lovin' You Tonight; II: Finders Keepers, Think, Are You Lonely For Me Baby, The Harder They Come Keystone Berkeley 1/18/74: I: It's No Use, Expressway, Roadrunner, Like A Road, Mystery Train, The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down; II: The Harder They Come, Wonderin Why, C.C. Rider (w/ female vocalist) [set is incomplete on this tape]. Thanks to Jim Powell for sorting this out for me!" |
| Tech Notes | Garcia & Saunders Keystone; Berkeley, CA 1/18/74 PATCHED VERSION (discs one and two different from previously circulating version) MAC > D > CD > EAC > SHN Recorded by Bob Menke, unknown setup + MSR > D > CD patches from sbd portion that usually circulates as part of "Dick's Gift." Patching by Sean Cribbs. Subsequent extraction using EAC, retracking using CD Wave, sector boundary verification using shntool, .shn encoding using mkwACT, and seeding by Joe Jupille. Disc One (5) 70:03 Set I 1. Tuning [0:22] 2. Someday Baby [13:40] [2:18] 3. La-La [11:32] [2:18] 4. Second That Emotion [14:40] [1:10] 5. My Funny Valentine [24:25] [0:11] Disc Two (7) 71:06 Set I (con't) 1. Tuning [0:34] 2. Who's Lovin' You Tonight? [15:25] [0:26] Set II 3. //Finders Keepers [10:13#] [1:10] 4. Think [9:04] [1:33] 5. "Sure is quiet for Berkeley" [0:19] 6. Are You Lonely For Me Baby?// [15:23#] [0:08] 7. //It's No Use [16:38] [0:11] Disc Three (6) 62:10 Set II (con't) 1. Tuning [1:34] 2. Expressway [11:39] [1:02] 3. Roadrunner [11:35] [0:26] 4. Like a Road [14:10] [0:19] 5. Mystery// Train [13:08#] [0:59] 6. The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down [6:06] [0:10] set break Disc Four (5) 38:17 Set III 1. Tuning [1:05] 2. Harder They Come [14:45] [0:56] 3. Wondering Why [10:39] [0:30] 4. Banter/Tuning [3:27] 5. C.C. Rider [6:37] [0:15] Flaws/Notes: d1t04 Second That Emotion light tick @ 4:22 d1t05 My Funny Valentine light crackles just before patch, @ 6:01, 6:04-6:06. These were present on the unpatched version as well. d2t02 Finders Keepers cuts in, not much missing d2t02-03 pop just before track marker d2t06 Lonely for Me (master?) anomalies @ 10:36-11:04 d2t06 Lonely for Me cuts out d2t07 It's No Use cuts in, not much missing d3t04 Like a Road crackles @ 1:17, 1:24, 1:43, 3:02, 2:03-2:05, 2:14 d3t05 Mystery Train cut/splice @ 3:11 d4t05 C.C. Rider guest vocalist, maybe Roger Troy? Additional Notes: Variable speed problems throughout, though absent those problems (which really aren't that distracting)this is an excellent recording. I will not note specific speed-related anomalies in these flaw notes. This is tracked and noted as a three-set show, consistent with the taper's recollection and notations. However, it seems at least possible that this material derives from two separate shows, either from 1/17 and 1/18 or from early and late shows on the 18th. First, the show is longer in terms of sets and minutes than just about any other Garcia & Saunders show on record. Second, Finders Keepers, Think, the "sure is quiet for Berkeley" comment, and Are You Lonely For Me Baby? have circulated since at least 1990 with a date of 1/17 (albeit 1973, which seems clearly incorrect). Third, the tuning break during "set III" (disc four) has two separate audience members calling for songs that appear earlier on this recording (Finders Keepers and Second That Emotion). While it seems unlikely that two separate audience members would have forgotten what had been played only an hour or two earlier and/or requested that a song be repeated, some who attended shows at the Keystone suggest that, with all of the comings and goings (etc.), it might have been possible. Ultimately, we will probably never know, but this material rocks nonetheless! |
| J-Card Comment | Garcia & Saunders Recorded by Bob Menke, unknown setup. |
| Trades Allowed | Yes |
Owned by Warren Oates
· Last Updated May 23, 2023
Add Show
View Show