Loading...

Led Zeppelin 09/19/1970

SHOWID 214584

Set I

Immigrant Song
Heartbreaker
Dazed And Confused
Bring It On Home
That's The Way
Bron-Yr-Aur
Since I've Been Loving You
Organ Solo / Thank You
What Is And What Should Never Be

Set II

Moby Dick
Whole Lotta Love medley
Boogie Woogie
Truckin' Little Mama
For What It's Worth
Honey Bee
The Lemon Song
Communication Breakdown

Set III

 

Comment

Not to be confused with the evening show. This is an enjoyable show but it can't touch the evening show.

Collectors With This Show

User (active/rating) Media / # Show Sound Details DB Source User Source
Michael D. (5/0) FLAC / View  
Slick2007 (5/5) FLAC / 2 B+ View  
Molly (5/0) FLAC / 1 7 View  
OldNeumanntapr (5/5) FLAC / B View   Audience; 'Praying Silently For Jimi' Bootleg CD (Empress Valley)
Notes: (Afternoon Show) ********************************************* FLAC Tags Via xACT 2.50 By OldNeumanntapr *********************************************
OldNeumanntapr (5/5) FLAC / 0 B+ View   Unknown Audience (Tarantura 2000/TMQ 'Have You Ever Experienced?')
Notes: (Early Show) ******************************************************************************** Trade FLACs >WAV (Change File Names To Reflect Etree Standards, Separate Early And Late Shows) >FLAC (Level 8) + Tags Via xACT 2.47 By OldNeumanntapr ******************************************************************************** Text File Notes: This is Tarantura's 2000 mix of Source 1 and Source 2 to form a (more) complete show. I believe the majority of the mix is in the first show of the two being uploaded from this day in 1970. After listening to the second, evening show as I was making my previous post before sunrise yesterday (it will be by the time I post this), which is CD's 3 & 4, I believe that show was one source only. Whatever the case, whatever the source, this is a great-to-excellent 4 CD set of both the afternoon and evening shows on September 19, 1970. And the majority of the sound on both shows is what I call excellent (8-to-9 out of 10). These are my personal ratings and they may not be the same to you. I tend to base my own ratings on more than just sound and I let how much I like or enjoy the show enter in. It's not very scientific (o helpful?), but it is what it is. LINEAGE: Tarantura 2000 silver CD's > WAV > me > TLH (for CDDA testing & to aligning sector boundaries/fix SBE's*) > Audacity (to embed metadata/song titles and info and encode as FLAC) > FLAC 6 > TLH (to recheck project was error free and to create and verify md5 & ffp files) > you * I received these CD's in the WAV format originally a number of years back. I believe the person sharing them wasn't sure exactly what to do or how to losslessly compress and encode them and they were likely ripped with a bad CD burning program causing the SBE's and just left in the ripped WAV format. I've had the WAV files on my PC for years. As I was preparing this upload, I finally did all of the things everyone should learn to do to keep the integrity of the music as pure as possible. Every track had sector boundary errors, but with the help of TLH, they easily were fixed. My initial burn of the WAV files was just to get a listen in on the shows. Needless to say, I had a lot of pops and clicks in what I listened to due to the SBE's. But still having the WAV files, I was able to fix the errors from their initial rip yesterday and not have to fix them after a second rip from my snap, crackle, and pop CD's. The version I'm uploading is error free and from the direct WAV files I was given from the initial silver CD's burn, but of course, they're all fixed now. DETAILS: Artist: Led Zeppelin Date: September 19th, 1970 Location: New York, NY Venue: Madison Square Garden Source: AUD (both shows) Format: FLAC CD's: 2 Artwork: Yes Label: Tarantura 2000/TMQ Title: Have You Ever Experienced? Size: 1.47 GB
Metal Trader (5/5) CD / 2 8 View   AUD [1:52:08]
Metal Trader (5/5) DVD / 1 9.5 8.5 View   AUD [2:48]
Mike Marteny (5/5) cdr / 2 B+ View   "Have You Ever Experienced" bootleg>FLAC>CDR(1)
Notes: D1 68:39 D2 47:29
George Rue (5/5) Tape / 1 B+ View   Audience>3rd gen tape
Notes: Alternate Source. Immigrant Song thru Moby Dick. about 85 minutes.
George Rue (5/5) CD / 2 B++ View   Praying Silently For Jimi>MP3>WAV>CD
Notes: 112:31 min
chris payment (5/3.4) CDR / 2 View  
Notes: #195
David Bennett (5/5) cd / 2 A A View  
Jack Warner (5/5) FLAC / 0 View   MAC>C>C>CD, MAT>?>CD
sean hite (5/0) / 0 View  
Notes: afternoon show Combination of two audience recordings: Source 1, 2nd -> CD-R Source 2, Unknown gen -> CD-R Source 1 has better sound and was used where possible. Source 2 was used for: - most of Immigrant Song - Whole Lotta Love - Communication Breakdown - fixing many small cuts, dropouts and disturbances in source 1
sean hite (5/0) / 0 View  
Notes: " Praying Silently For Jimi" ( 9-19-70), New York City, New York, Madison Square Gardens, ( Afternoon Show) Audience Recording Lineage: Trader CD-R > EAC, Secure Mode, Accurate Stream, No Disable Cache > WAV > Flac Frontend, Encoding Options, Level.6, Align On Sector Boundaries > Flac > Label: Empress Valley Original Taper: N/A Cheers and thanks to my man in Japan Masahiro for hooking me up with this.
sean hite (5/0) / 0 View  
Notes: AMERICAN WOMAN THE DIAGRAMS OF LED ZEPPELIN TDOLZ Vol. 8 (18/19) CD1: (69:44) CD2: (39:26) Recording: Good-Very good mono audience. Source: Madison Square Garden, New York City, New York, New York Sept. 19 '70 afternoon show. Comments: Japanese bootleg. Deluxe jewel case. 1,000 copies made. Lineage: Original Silver > ? > CDR > EAC > WAV > FLAC > HD > Audacity lossless test > Dime Sound Quality IMO 6-7/10
richard (5/5) Cdr / 2 View  
Notes: Lossy Sourced
Brandon Moeller (5/5) CD-R / 2 View  
Notes: Downloaded from a thetradersden.org bit torrent.
Dwayne (5/5) cdr / 2 View   AUD
shadow121603 (5/0) Flac / 2 View   Afternoon show Title: Praying Silently For Jimi Label: Empress Valley Supreme Disc
Notes: Afternoon ShowTitle: Praying Silently For Jimi Label: Empress Valley Supreme Disc
robertofoo777 (5/4.3) CDR / 2 ?? ?? View  
Notes: Audience Recording Lineage: Trader CD-R > EAC, Secure Mode, Accurate Stream, No Disable Cache > WAV > Flac Frontend, Encoding Options, Level.6, Align On Sector Boundaries > Flac >
BH (5/5) flac / 1 View  
Notes: ABF/ABF RM/American Woman/BTP/OMFTR 2005/One More for the Road/Requiem
Joe (5/5) CD-R / 2 B View   Aud
Notes: American Woman - TDOLZ
Joe (5/5) CD-R / 2 View   Aud.
Notes: A Bit Frightening(Eddie Edwards Remaster)
ctg (5/0) / 0 View  
Steve K (4/5) FLAC / 2 B View   AUD
Notes: Combination of two audience recordings: Source 1, 2nd -> CD-R Source 2, Unknown gen -> CD-R Source 1 has better sound and was used where possible.
Michael Shilling (4/5) CDR / 2 B View  
Notes: "Praying Silently For Jimi" (Empress Valley. Only reason to have this tape is for the historic significance of Robert's comments re: Jimi's passing. Otherwise unless a completist - take a pass on this one. A combination of a few audience tapes to make a more complete recording. The Edits between sources is very evident with major Sound quality variance.
Edgar H (4/5) / 2 View   "Have You Ever Experienced" (Tarantura)
Notes: comes with the evening show.
Ron (4/5) CDR / 2 B View   Unknown gen audience source
Notes: Early show
Jeff Williams (4/0) FLAC / 2 View   AUD
Notes: Praying Silently For Jimi
Antoine Joly (4/0) FLAC / 0 View   "One More For The Road: 2005 Edition"
Bohac (4/0) shn / 0 View  
dcbullet (4/5) SHN / 0 View   Combination of two audience recordings (by Eddie Edwards)
Notes: Source 1, 2nd -> CD-R Source 2, Unknown gen -> CD-R
Mike (4/5) cdr / 2 B B View  
Notes: Afternoon Show
Jimmy Mac (4/0) cdr / 2 View  
Notes: A Bit Frightening - Eddie Edwards Remaster
Jimmy Mac (4/0) cdr / 2 View  
Notes: American Woman
Michael (3/0) FLAC / 2 View  
zowie (3/5) cd / 2 a- View   aud
J (3/0) / 0 View  
Ledhed (3/5) CDR / 4 View   AUD
Notes: 'Have You Ever Experenced' (Tarantura) Afternoon and Evening show
weedwacker (3/0) .shn / 0 View   aud
Notes: American Woman (TDOLZ)
weedwacker (3/0) .flac / 0 A A View   aud
Notes: A Bit Frightening (Eddie Edwards) best version of this show.
Jeff Laqua (3/0) CDR / 2 View  
dr (3/5) flac / 0 View  
Notes: A Bit Frightening Eddie
Brandon Haffner (3/0) CDR / 2 A B- View  
Ryan Curtis (3/0) / 0 View   American Woman
Jascha Dub (3/0) FLAC / 2 A B+ View  
Notes: Combination of two audience recordings: Source 1, 2nd -> CD-R Source 2, Unknown gen -> CD-R
Charlie Rich (3/4.7) CDR / 1 EX- View   Aud
Notes: "Maui Wowie"
RM's Giant Live Music Archive (2/5) FLAC / 0 View   "Praying Silently For Jimi" (Empress Valley) (SS109)
Notes: Led Zeppelin - "Praying Silently For Jimi" (09-19-70), New York City, New York, Madison Square Gardens, (Afternoon Show) Audience Recording Lineage: Trader CD-R > EAC, Secure Mode, Accurate Stream, No Disable Cache > WAV > Flac Frontend, Encoding Options, Level.6, Align On Sector Boundaries > Flac > Label: Empress Valley Original Taper: N/A
RM's Giant Live Music Archive (2/5) FLAC / 0 View   "A Bit Frightening" AKA Eddie Edwards' 2004 remaster (AE002)
Notes: Combination of two audience recordings: Source 1, 2nd -> CD-R Source 2, Unknown gen -> CD-R Source 1 has better sound and was used where possible. Source 2 was used for: - most of Immigrant Song - Whole Lotta Love - Communication Breakdown - fixing many small cuts, dropouts and disturbances in source 1
RM's Giant Live Music Archive (2/5) FLAC / 0 View   "Have You Ever Experienced" (Tarantura 2004) (D106 & AA076)
Notes: liberated Tarantura 2004 bootleg. lineage: My silvers > EAC > WAV > FLAC FRONTEND > FLAC Level 8, tested encoded files and Checksum md5 generated by Traders' Little Helper
RM's Giant Live Music Archive (2/5) FLAC / 0 View   "Madison Square Garden 1970 Revisited" (no label) (QQ073)
Notes: "Madison Square Garden 1970 Revisited" 4CD - No Label, 2020 Disc 1-2: Afternoon Show Disc 3-4: Evening Show Silver CDs>EAC (secure)>WAV>FLAC
King of the Gypsies (2/5) / View  
OBIE (2/5) FLAC / 2 View  
Erick (2/3) FLAC / 2 View  
Ed (2/4.2) cdr/flac / 2 View   aud
Notes: Lineage: Trader CD-R > EAC, Secure Mode, Accurate Stream, No Disable Cache > WAV > Flac Frontend, Encoding Options, Level.6, Align On Sector Boundaries > Flac > Label: Empress Valley Original Taper: N/A
Tim (2/0) CDR / 2 View  
Notes: A Bit Frightening CD audience 1:52:08
Tim (2/0) CDR / 2 View   Empress Valley
Notes: Praying Silently For Jimi CD audience 1:52:58
Tim (2/0) CDR / 2 View   Tarantura 2004, The Acrobat Edition
Notes: Have You Ever Experienced, Afternoon & Evening Show CD 1:52:08
Tim (2/0) CDR / 2 View   TDOLZ
Notes: American Woman CD audience 1:49:07
Scott J (2/0) / 2 View  
Nathan Hevenstone (2/0) CD-R / 2 A B View  
Scott Brown (2/5) cdr / 2 View  
Notes: "American Woman" (TDOLZ) -afternoon show-
Brian (2/5) CDR / 2 View  
alex (2/0) CDR / 4 View  
Notes: ?HAVE YOU EVER EXPERIENCED?? (Tarantura)
Joel Means (2/5) FLAC / 1 View  
Notes: American Woman - TDOLZ
Joel Means (2/5) FLAC / 2 View   2nd gen > CDR, unknown gen > CDR
Notes: Eddie Edwards Remaster (two sources) - 2nd gen > CDR, unknown gen > CDR
John Peters (1/0) FLAC / 1 View   2 Sources: AUD: 2nd Gen Analog > CD-R; AUD: Unknown Gen > CDR
Notes: "A Bit Frightening"
Boedi-taper (1/4.8) CDR / 2 A B+ View  
Notes: Audience recording
Carter (1/5) CDR / 2 View  
michael rosenberg (1/5) flac / 1 View   AUD - CDs>EAC (secure)>WAV>FLAC
Preston Klingler (1/4.9) FLAC / 1 View   Unknown Rec. Equipment Gen: Silver Storming The Big Apple > FLAC
Pete (1/5) cd-r / 2 View  
Stuart Ferguson (1/4.7) CDR / 2 View   Audience
Notes: DVD 994; lineage: Audience recording. "Have You Ever Experienced" (Tarantura 2004, The Acrobat Edition) silvers>EAC>WAV>FLACFRONTEND>FLAC Level 8, tested encoded files and Checksum md5 generated by Traders' Little Helper
Hanf (1/5) Shn / 0 View  
Notes: American Woman (TDOLZ)
Axel (1/5) CD / 2 A- B+ View   tradersden - 660MB flac
Notes: tradersden - 660MB flac
Maria Reine (1/5) CD-R / 2 View  
Notes: "Praying Silently For Jimi" [Empress Valley EVSD 310/311]. Audience recording. FLAC[sg1500b]
Charlie (1/0) / 0 View  
Jeffrey Peterson (1/4.9) CDR / 2 View  
William (1/0) FLAC / 2 View  
bluibootleg (1/0) FLAC / 0 View   Audience
Martin McNally (1/0) FLAC / 2 View   AUD
Notes: EVSD Praying Silently For Jimi 707MB
Sandy Cook (1/5) FLAC / 1 View  
Notes: Liberated bootleg "American Woman" afternoon show
Greg Evans (1/0) FLAC x / 2 AUD View   Combination of two audience recordings: Source 1, 2nd -> CD-R. Source 2, Unknown gen -> CD-R
Notes: Combination of two audience recordings: Source 1, 2nd -> CD-R. Source 2, Unknown gen -> CD-R
tarkus22 (1/5) FLAC / 2 View  
Notes: A Bit Frightening (Eddie Edwards)
tarkus22 (1/5) FLAC / 2 View  
Notes: American Woman (TDOLZ)
tarkus22 (1/5) FLAC / 2 View  
Notes: " Praying Silently For Jimi" Lineage: Trader CD-R > EAC, Secure Mode, Accurate Stream, No Disable Cache > WAV > Flac Frontend, Encoding Options, Level.6, Align On Sector Boundaries > Flac > Label: Empress Valley
caprice (1/5) CDR / 2 View   AUD, 2nd/Unknown gen -> CD-R
Notes: Combination of two audience recordings (Eddie Edwards)
Alex (1/4.5) cdr / 2 A B View  
Notes: 'American woman' AUD recording. not as good as the evening show
Alex (1/4.5) cdr / 2 A B View  
Notes: 'a bit frightening' eddie edwards remaster. fair audience recording
Bob (1/0) CDr, flac / 2 A B- View   AUD: Source 1, 2nd -> CD-R;Source 2, Unknown gen -> CD-R
Notes: "A Bit Frightening"
Brian (0/0) / 0 View   unknown.empressvalleyboot.EVSD310-311.shnf
Selman Snow (0/0) Flac / 2 View  
Skip Jenkins (0/5) flac, CD-R / 1 View   Praying Silently For Jimi (Empress Valley)
Bill Tripp (0/5) FLAC / 1 View   Silver>CDR(?)>EAC>WAV>FLAC
Notes: 1 FLAC / 2 CDR - "American Woman" (TDOLZ)
Bill Tripp (0/5) FLAC / 1 View   2 sources, see notes
Notes: "A Bit Frigtening" - (Eddie Edwards Edition) Disc 1 - ABF_d1t1 Immigrant Song ABF_d1t2 Heartbreaker ABF_d1t3 Dazed and Confused ABF_d1t4 Bring It On Home ABF_d1t5 That's The Way ABF_d1t6 Bron-Yr-Aur ABF_d1t7 Since I've Been Loving You ABF_d1t8 Thank You Disc 2 - ABF_d2t1 What Is and What Should Never Be ABF_d2t2 Moby Dick ABF_d2t3 Whole Lotta Love ABF_d2t4 Communication Breakdown Combination of two audience recordings: Source 1, 2nd -> CD-R Source 2, Unknown gen -> CD-R Source 1 has better sound and was used where possible. Source 2 was used for: - most of Immigrant Song - Whole Lotta Love - Communication Breakdown - fixing many small cuts, dropouts and disturbances in source 1
steve (0/0) CD-R / 2 View   " American Woman", Afternoon Show, TDOLZ, Trader CD-R
Notes: " American Woman",TDOLZ, Afternoon Show. Trader Cd-R
steve (0/0) Flac / 2 View   " A Bit Frightening", Eddie Edwards, Two Audience Source Merge
Notes: " A Bit Frightening" Eddie Edwards. Two Audience Recording Source Merge.
steve (0/0) CD-R / 2 View   " Praying Silently For Jimi", Empress Valley, Trader CD-R
Notes: " Praying Silently For Jimi", Empress Valley Trader CD-R
Jon (0/0) AUD/FLAC / 2 View   2nd -> CD-R